Hydroponic Garden Shop Has Attention Of Deputies Searching For Marijuana Growers

[LongHairBri]

St. Petersburg Times

 

LARGO — Last fall, a white Chevy truck pulled into the parking lot of a hydroponic gardening shop on Ulmerton Road.

 

A man went in, purchased some supplies and drove off.

 

Someone was watching.

 

Detectives with the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office, watching via a camera mounted on a pole nearby, recorded the Chevy's license plate number, checked motor vehicle records to identify the owner, and soon showed up at his home in Seminole.

 

Allen Underwood is one of dozens of Pinellas residents investigated by deputies over the past two years on suspicion of cultivating marijuana.

 

A part-time handyman with only a misdemeanor driving infraction on his record, Underwood made his way onto detectives' radar for one reason: He shopped at Simply Hydroponics.

 

• • •

 

For more than two years, Pinellas deputies have watched customers of Simply Hydroponics through the surreptitiously placed camera.

 

The Pinellas County Sheriff's Office defends its spying on Simply Hydroponics, saying it is a known fact that indoor marijuana growers frequent hydroponic shops.

 

The St. Petersburg Times reviewed 450 search warrants filed in Pinellas between Jan. 1, 2010, and Sept. 15, 2011, and found 39 warrants that began with surveillance at Simply Hydroponics.

 

The outcome of those cases tends to support the Sheriff's Office defense of the tactic: In each of the 39 cases, detectives found either some marijuana or marijuana plants in the homes they searched.

 

"It tells me where there's smoke, there's fire. They're on to something," said Pinellas Sheriff Bob Gualtieri.

 

But the surveillance of Simply Hydroponics, while legal, has riled the owners of the business as well as local defense attorneys who say citizens are being unfairly watched and investigated.

 

"It's wrong, completely wrong, that a law enforcement agency will target what is, on its face, a legitimate business and target the customers of that business simply because they show up on camera going into a store where it's legal to shop," said attorney John Trevena of Largo, who is representing some of the defendants.

 

The surveillance isn't the only tool being used by Pinellas sheriff's investigators that is raising questions. Allen Underwood's attorney claims Pinellas deputies trespassed on his client's property and destroyed evidence. Several other attorneys say they believe deputies lied when they told judges they can smell growing marijuana — in one case, just a single plant — from outside a house.

 

• • •

 

Detectives saw a vehicle belonging to John Ray at Simply Hydroponics in March 2009, according to an affidavit. More than a year later, on May 25, 2010, they showed up at Ray's St. Petersburg home and asked if he was growing marijuana.

 

Ray said he wasn't. Ray said the deputies asked to search his home. He refused.

 

Later, in a search warrant affidavit, detectives wrote that after Ray closed the door, they smelled growing marijuana and heard "the distinct sound of foliage being broken" — though experts consulted by the Times said marijuana plants are pliable and would only make a sound similar to a tomato plant being broken.

 

Law enforcement officers are permitted to enter a home without a warrant if they believe evidence is being destroyed. Ray said deputies broke through his iron gate and were outside his front door when he opened it.

 

"I didn't even get it halfway open and they were dragging me out," recalled Ray, who told the Times he didn't shop at Simply Hydroponics.

 

Ray said he spent the next eight or nine hours handcuffed in his courtyard while deputies went to a judge to get a warrant, then searched his home. They found one plant — a plant Ray said he believes was left in his garage months earlier when a relative moved out. He said he didn't know it was there.

 

The experience, he said, still upsets him.

 

"I lay in bed sometimes, scared, thinking about what they can get away with," Ray said. "You think you're living in America, you're safe. You're not. They can do whatever they want. They're above the law."

 

• • •

 

Hydroponics utilizes water and nutrients, but no soil. It is used to grow many types of plants, but it's popular with marijuana cultivators, especially in built-out Pinellas County, where indoor operations are growers' only option.

 

Sheriff Gualtieri says that watching customers of Simply Hydroponics is a successful investigative technique when combined with other information such as tips, prior intelligence, a suspect's criminal history — and common sense.

 

"There are some businesses in this county that, while they are selling a product that could be used for legal purposes, it is notorious to be used for illegal purposes … ," he said. "Our experience tells us that people involved in grow houses do buy materials at hydroponics shops."

 

William T. Gaut, a criminal justice consultant from Naples, said it isn't improper to use "pole cams" as a covert surveillance method. Seeing someone visit a garden shop does not establish probable cause for a search warrant but can be combined with other information such as unusually high power usage or tips from reliable sources, he said.

 

"The surveillance that you see on the pole cam, it can form one small part of reasonable suspicion, but you can't act on it solely with no other evidence. If you do that, now you're over the line and infringing on constitutional rights," Gaut said.

 

Dawn Bednar, co-owner of Simply Hydroponics, said she "doesn't appreciate the picture that's being painted" by detectives of her shop.

 

"They're not entitled to harass a business and customers for where they shop. Everyone who visits a gun shop isn't a murderer," Bednar said. "We're trying to help people grow pesticide-free food. That isn't a crime."

 

Pinellas investigators, after identifying the store's customers and finding their home addresses, generally would check out how much electricity they were using. Markedly higher usage can indicate a grow operation.

 

In most cases, detectives would then conduct "spot checks" at the homes to look for signs of a grow operation, such as humming motors and blacked-out windows. They also sniffed — to see if they could smell marijuana wafting from the home.

 

If detectives believed marijuana was being grown, they wrote an affidavit explaining their probable cause — the information that gave them a reasonable belief a crime was being committed. That would be presented to a judge, who would authorize or reject the search.

 

In nearly all of the Simply Hydroponics-related warrants, detectives told Pinellas judges they could stand outside a home and smell growing marijuana. But some experts say it is improbable, if not impossible, for officers to smell marijuana growing inside a closed structure.

 

Dr. Richard Doty, the director of the Smell and Taste Center at the University of Pennsylvania, has conducted experiments to test whether people are able to smell marijuana from outside a home where plants are being grown. Insulation and ventilation of the home, the maturity of the plants and the distance between the nose and odor source can affect that ability.

 

Young plants don't emit an odor, but if a person were growing "hundreds" of mature plants in a structure that wasn't properly sealed, it's "possible" an officer very close to the home would notice the smell, Doty said.

 

James Woodford of Chattanooga, Tenn., an expert on the topic of marijuana odor, said a large operation vented directly outdoors could generate an occasional "whiff" of marijuana detectable up to 25 to 30 feet away.

 

In the case of Allen Underwood, the Seminole man deputies spotted at Simply Hydroponics in 2010, detectives said they twice smelled marijuana from a sidewalk that was 15 to 20 feet from his home. Underwood's attorney, Jerry Theophilopoulos, says the sidewalk was nearly 70 feet from the alleged grow room.

 

Law enforcement officers commonly use the smell of marijuana to establish probable cause. "Many such claims defy common sense, even though the courts routinely accept them as truth," Doty said.

 

Former Pinellas Sheriff's Office narcotics supervisor Capt. Robert Alfonso, who retired in October, disagreed, saying growing marijuana has a strong odor easily identified by professionals.

 

According to records, detectives found 10 mature marijuana plants and about a dozen seedlings at Underwood's home. In June, Underwood, who declined to comment for this story, was convicted of manufacturing marijuana with the intent to distribute and sentenced to probation.

 

• • •

 

Theophilopoulos, Underwood's attorney, filed an internal affairs complaint with the Sheriff's Office alleging impropriety by deputies, including trespassing, dishonesty in their search warrant request and erasure of Underwood's DVR hard drive, which was connected to a home surveillance camera.

 

The recording was erased, Alfonso said, because it contained images of undercover officers; a supervisor worried it might compromise their safety. The DVR was not locked up as evidence should be, Alfonso acknowledged. He said he "put out a directive to make sure this never happens again and everything that's taken out of a residence is treated as evidence."

 

In a court filing, the U.S. Attorney for the Middle District of Florida admonished the Sheriff's Office for the erasure.

 

Theophilopoulos contends the recorder contained images showing detectives trespassed on Underwood's property and were not at his home when they said they were.

 

"It would have gone a long way to proving that the allegations sworn to in the affidavit weren't true," he said.

 

Theophilopoulos and other attorneys interviewed by the Times said they're convinced not only that the surveillance tactics are overreaching, but also that some Pinellas narcotics detectives are being untruthful in their search warrant affidavits.

 

"They're misleading the courts," Theophilopoulos said, "and it's intentional."

[The Digital Nomad]

Well the point of the story - you should still follow security procedures driving home. Don't drive directly home, make sure you can drive a part of the route and observe if you have a tail. It is pretty true - LEO could very well 'fish' at a hydro store for prospective marijuana growers. Imagine if they choose which ones to target by who has the nicer vehicle...

 

DN

[ilynnboy]

The lenghts that they will go through / stoop to are unreal. Really??

Because someone wants to feel better whether that be physically (pain) or mentally( mood elevation ) ?

C'mon cops get over it already. I could mak some stereotypical comment about cops going home to their alcohol and battered wives but I won't. It's not nice to stereotype.

[Medcnman]

Can you say "Profiling?" Medcnman.

[Nix]

Agreed with Nomad. Pretend like it's still illegal and you'll be paranoid and on the look out.

[Michigan Medical Gardens]

someone go with a mask on and destroy the darn video cam.. now we know its there. lol

[purklize]

Don't park in the hydro shop's parking lot. Park a block or two away and walk.

[free country 420]

yea looking for a tail is no good...cause if u have a tail its too late they got yea....

[medicinejeff]

Don't park in the hydro shop's parking lot. Park a block or two away and walk.

 

 

 

I totally did this the first time I bought a light. Now days I just park. Figured "Yeah, cuz THAT wouldn't look weird" to someone watching the lot...

Good head's up. It would be nice for these gentlemen to think about us and the owner's (paying taxes) as not a nuisance, but rather the 7 officers who aren't having to be laid off. We are the 7 officers. Something likke that on a Weed Wars show or was it Ganjapreneurs?

[Budz-4-U]

How many blocks can I carry a 60 pound bag of ProMix-HP ?? None, I had back surgery. I park in the parking lot.

 

Thanks to a Patient I no longer have, the cops now know me, my car, and my grow room. So, it doesn't matter any more.

 

Keep your numbers straight. Plants and useable amounts. If you are legal, they can only ILLEGALLY harass you.

 

State already has your name and number. If you are legal, do what I did: If they jail/harass you, simply hire a Lawyer.

 

If they harass you multiple times, SUE them. Staying legal, knowing you are legal, knowing you are right and they are wrong, and knowing a good Lawyer, is the key.

 

Once you know, that they know, that you are legal and are aware of your rights, gives you the upper hand. Not what I wanted, but it happened, and, it's OK. Can't change it now.

 

Peace.

[purklize]

I think most employees would be willing to carry supplies to your car if you need the help. If they weren't Id just shop elsewhere as they're probably inconsiderate. If the camera is trained on the lot, even parking 2 stores down could help. As far as it looking shady, well, they think EVERYONE shopping there is shady, so you've got nothing to lose there.

[pic book]

Need any more reasons to grow in horse manure in 55 gallon drums?

[DailyToker]

A lot of shops around me deliver.

[mike44]

This same thing was done by the Fed's in the early 80's here in Michigan. Camera in the transformer on the power pole. East Lansing. They actually charged the business owner for selling hydro supplies. Took the owners a few years and tons of money to fight them.

It was around 1980 I think, and the company is still doing business today. Maybe some of you can remember, as there were a couple large busts in Lansing due to the surveillance.

[Frank R]

I'd say the best thing is to desensitize LEO to grow shops by calling them to come to the grow shops for whatever legal valid, yet innocous reasons are plausible.

 

Much like with shop lifting, B&E, domestic abuse, child abuse, etc LEO will just yawn and turn off their radios when they hear about something going on at the grow shop after they've had to go their a few times....

 

Unless there is something to seize, LEO aint got no time for your petty crimes....

 

 

"In 2008, when Flint had 265 sworn officers on their police force, there were 35 murders and 91 rapes in this city. In 2010, when Flint had only 144 police officers, the murder rate climbed to 65, and rapes … climbed to 229."

 

Joe Biden on Wednesday, October 12th, 2011 in Flint, Mich.

[Inepsa]

This is very ridiculous that police are doing this, they already get inside info from power company's anyways.

[Mememe]

I thought smell was no longer grounds for probable cause?